Submitted Testimony: Docket #0277 — BPS Special Education

November 9, 2026 

Dear Chair Mejia, Councilor Murphy, and members of the Committee on Education:

My name is Mary Tamer and I am Executive Director of MassPotential and a founding member of Next Chapter Boston. I respectfully submit this written testimony for the record on Docket #0277, the order for a hearing to audit Boston Public Schools' special education services and return on investment. Thank you for taking up this important question.

This school year, BPS will spend approximately $476 million dollars on special education. These dollars are meant to provide essential services for more than 10,000 Boston children with disabilities, including the specific instruction and support they are legally promised in their IEPs. The question before this Committee is not whether that investment matters; it is whether those children are getting what we are paying for. Based on four years of data, we can clearly say they are not.

Children are still being taught in substantially separate settings

In 2022, MA DESE found special education in Boston in "systemic disarray." An outside review found that 29% of students with disabilities were taught in substantially separate classrooms, more than double the state rate. The same review found that Boston refers Black and Latino boys and English learners to special education at disproportionate rates.

At the time, BPS committed to change. Yet as of October 2025, state Corrective Action Plan data still show about 28% of students with disabilities in substantially separate settings, essentially unchanged after three years of a Systemic Improvement Plan. That is roughly 3,000 children who spend most of their school day away from their classmates. For Black students with disabilities, the rate is 34% (twice the rate of white students). And it starts early: 46.9% of Boston's three- to five-year-olds with disabilities are placed in substantially separate settings before they ever reach kindergarten (more than double the state average).

Behind each of those numbers is a child. The Globe reported on a 10-year-old Mattapan boy who is nonverbal and uses a wheelchair. For six years, his school could not teach him alongside other children, so he often learned alone in a separate room, and his mother said it was crushing him. Within a year of moving to an inclusive school with the staff to support him, he wrote his own name without guidance for the first time. Inclusion works when it is properly resourced. 

Disproportional outcomes

  • In BPS, the class of 2025 (the first graduating class without the MCAS requirement) posted a “record” district graduation rate of 81% (as the district set a low bar of D- as a “passing” grade in all subjects). For students with disabilities, it was 66%, a 15 percentage-point gap. 

  • Students with disabilities in BLS come to school less frequently; and while the recent chronic absentee rate for SWDs is 39% compared to all students at 31%. 

  • On the most recent 2026 MCAS, only 6-9% of students with disabilities in grades 3 through 5 were meeting expectations in reading. Put plainly: of every 10 Boston third, fourth, and fifth graders with an IEP, at most one is reading on grade level. Reading is the gateway to every other subject. A child who cannot read by third grade cannot read the science textbook, the word problem, or the history assignment that follows, and every service we add later costs more money and accomplishes less.

Needs are growing while support is shrinking

The share of BPS students with disabilities grew from 21% in 2020 to 24% today, nearly one in four children. Boston has not responded to that growth by underspending. But a growing share of each dollar is going to the costs of failure, not to support students in the classroom.

BPS spends $49 million to place 450 students out of district, about $109,000 per student, often because their needs could not be met in their own neighborhood schools. This year’s budget also increased spending on lawyers for special education disputes with families sixfold. At the same time, budget cuts eliminated more than 100 special education aide positions and additional full-time special education roles. These are the adults who make inclusion possible.

At the same time, we continue to hear from advocates who represent families of students with disabilities, as well as families directly, that they are being told that their child needs evidence-based instruction in reading (as one consistent example), yet no teachers in certain school buildings have teachers with the proper training, a direct violation of IDEA. 

Boston does not need to spend more on special education. It needs to spend smarter. Every dollar that keeps a child learning well in their own neighborhood school is a dollar that does not have to be spent on an out-of-district placement, a legal dispute, or years of remediation later. 

What we believe this audit should deliver:

  1. Follow the money to outcomes. Report special education spending by school and program, next to results: literacy outcomes, graduation, and life after high school.

  2. Make the data public every year. A standing dashboard for students with disabilities, with multi-year trends.

  3. Fund what works. Protect the staffing inclusion requires, and put early literacy screening and evidence-based reading instruction, now required under the state's Right to Read Act, at the center of the plan, because reading difficulties drive many special education referrals.

Boston families are not asking for more spending. They are asking for results. They are asking for their children to learn alongside their peers, to read, and to walk across the stage with a diploma that means something. These children have already waited four-plus years for the promises of 2022. They should not have to wait any longer.

Thank you for your attention to this critical issue.

Respectfully submitted,

Mary Tamer 

Executive Director

MassPotential


BPS Data Appendix 

Across placement, graduation, literacy, and cost, outcomes for BPS students with disabilities have moved little while spending and identification have grown.

BPS Data Appendix: Students with Disabilities
MeasurePast DataLatest DataSource
4-year graduation rate, students with disabilities55.6% (class of 2016)66.1% (class of 2025) vs. 81.3% all studentsBPS 2017; DESE
Still enrolled after 4 years, students with disabilities—25.3% (class of 2025) vs. 9.5% all studentsDESE
Substantially separate placement, ages K–2129% (2022 review; state 14%, nation 13%)28.5% (Oct 2024); ~28% (Oct 2025)WBUR; DESE CAP
Substantially separate placement, ages 3–553.7% (Oct 2024)43.2% (Oct 2025)DESE CAP
Black students with disabilities in substantially separate settings—34.2% (Oct 2025)DESE CAP
Grades 3–5 students with disabilities not meeting MCAS reading expectations—More than 90% (2026)DESE
Share of BPS students with disabilities21% (2020)24.2% (2025–26; about 11,500 students)Boston Globe; Docket #0277
Special education general-fund budget$456.7M (FY26)$476M (FY27), 27.8% of general fundBMRB
Out-of-district placements—$49M for 450 students (FY26), about $109,000 eachCity of Boston FY26 budget
Special education staffing change—−106.4 aide FTEs (−6.9%); +21.4 teacher FTEs (FY27 proposed)



Previous
Previous

Testimony for the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education

Next
Next

Mississippi Fixed Its Schools. Here’s How Other States Can Too.