Testimony for the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education

November 17, 2026

Good morning, Secretary, Commissioner, Chair and members of the Board. My name is Erin Cooley, Deputy Director of MassPotential, speaking on behalf of the Voices for Academic Equity Coalition.

Since voters removed MCAS as a graduation requirement, each district now sets its own bar for a diploma. Yesterday our coalition released Ready or Not?, a report you can find on our website, with an analysis of what those bars are, based on the policies districts submitted to DESE. There are four key findings:

First, the bar is low. Seventy-three percent of districts set a passing grade at 65 percent or below, and some go as low as 50. Yet state law still requires that a diploma must represent demonstrated mastery of a common core of skills and knowledge.

Second, there is no common measure of mastery. Districts may use a final exam, a portfolio, or an “equivalent measure” of their choosing, with no independent validation of what those measures indicate. In addition, each of these measures relies predominantly on grades, which are increasingly inflated, leaving students and families with a false impression of what they are prepared to do after high school.

Third, diplomas and learning are diverging. In some districts – particularly those serving large percentages of students of color, multilingual learners, and low-income families – half of tenth graders are not meeting expectations, yet more than 80 percent are receiving a diploma indicating they are prepared for what’s next. When scores indicate a lack of preparedness, but students are awarded a diploma regardless, it sends confusing, and harmful messages. These students are left to discover their lack of preparedness when they arrive at college, apply for a job that requires a skill they don’t have, or take on student debt they can’t cover because they can’t keep up in the postsecondary program they’ve selected.

Fourth, this low bar matters long after graduation. Ten years out, graduates from one district can earn tens of thousands of dollars more than peers in neighboring districts and those gaps will likely increase over time.

To be clear, this isn’t about low expectations in cities, some of which have higher requirements than our suburban districts. The problem is a system with no floor – one that lets some students “demonstrate mastery” by earning a 50 percent in their course.

We ask the Board to act on two things. First, set a statewide minimum passing score for course credit that actually indicates mastery, which you can do now, without new legislation. Second, build on the Graduation Council’s recommendation for state-designed end-of-course assessments that matter to students, so every diploma includes an objective check about what students are prepared to do.

Every family deserves to know that their child’s diploma means they are prepared. Thank you.

Next
Next

Submitted Testimony: Docket #0277 — BPS Special Education